• Mario as Marlin
  • Jeffy as Nemo
  • Homestar Runner (from Homestar Runner) as Dory (genderbent role)
  • Brooklyn T. Guy as Gill
  • Shrek as Bloat
  • Sharon as Peach
  • Mr. Pig as Gurgle
  • Tony The Tiger as Bubbles
  • Emily Coleman as Deb
  • Jackie Chu as Jacques
  • Woody as Nigel
  • Bowser as Crush
  • Bowser Jr. as Squirt
  • Joseph, Cody and Toadette as Tad, Sheldon and Pearl
  • Chef Pee Pee as Mr. Ray
  • Black Yoshi as Bruce
  • Wario and Waluigi (from Mario) as Anchor and Chum
  • Toad as Blenny the Worried Fish
  • Gotta Sweep (from Baldi's Basics in Education and Learning) as The Anglerfish
  • Mine Bird as The Seagulls
  • Red Guy (from Don't Hug Me I'm Scared) as The Whale
  • Mr. Winkle as Dr. Philip Sherman
  • Princess Peach as Darla Sherman
  • Rosalina as Coral
  • Strong Bad (from Homestar Runner) as Barracuda
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.